Jewelry repair questions · Earrings & pendants

How do I clean silver earrings and disinfect them safely, even tarnished ones?

Wash them in warm water with a drop of mild dish soap, brush the posts, hooks and backs with a soft toothbrush, then rinse and dry them well. To disinfect, wipe the posts with rubbing alcohol. Lift light tarnish with a silver polishing cloth, and save silver polish for plain, solid sterling without pearls or soft stones.

From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )

60–90%alcohol-in-water range the CDC gives as most effective against bacteria
Below 50%relative humidity for storing silver to slow tarnish (Sheffield Assay Office)
$44Jewelry Spa for silver earrings: ultrasonic, steam, hand polish and a written report
50,000+repairs since 1989 at Sky Jewelry's New York studio

The short version

  • Everyday clean: warm water, a drop of mild dish soap, a soft toothbrush on the posts and backs, a rinse in a bowl rather than over an open drain, and a thorough dry.
  • Disinfect: wipe or dip the posts, hooks and backs in rubbing alcohol and let them air-dry. Jewelers Mutual suggests rubbing alcohol or hydrogen peroxide for extra disinfection.
  • Light tarnish: a silver polishing cloth.
  • Dark or black tarnish: a silver polish on plain, solid sterling, washed out completely afterwards.
  • Avoid: toothpaste, bleach, acetone and chlorinated pool water, and keep dips away from pearls, stones, glued parts and blackened designs.
  • Store them dry and apart, in a pouch or small sealed bag, ideally below 50% relative humidity.

Prices

Service PriceWhat's included
Jewelry Spa from $44Ultrasonic bath, steam and hand polish, with a written inspection report. Silver earrings $44; 14K yellow gold earrings $59 ($44 + $10 + $5).
Jewelry Polishing from $30Heavy tarnish and fine scratches worked out through progressively finer compounds, details by hand. Silver earrings $30; 14K yellow gold $55 ($30 + $17 + $8).
Rhodium Plating from $89 for silver earringsPolished, cleaned and plated with rhodium, which keeps tarnish off sterling while it lasts ($69 + $20 for earrings).
Earring Post Repair from $30A bent, snapped or worn post replaced by soldering or laser welding, never glue. Silver stick-post pair $30, single earring $20; a worn leverback that won't snap shut $60 a pair in silver ($30 + $30); 14K yellow gold stick-post pair $40 ($30 + $6 + $4).

Cleaning and disinfecting are different jobs

Earrings collect more than most jewelry: skin oil, lotion, hair product and dead skin build up where the post meets the earring and inside butterfly backs. Jewelers Mutual stresses cleaning the posts and backs in particular, both for the metal and to help prevent infection; if a pair has started to smell, see why earrings smell. Three different things happen to silver earrings, and each has its own fix:

  • Grime sits on the surface. Soap and water lift it, and a toothpick or cotton swab reaches inside the back and around the base of the post.
  • Germs are what disinfecting is for. The CDC gives 60% to 90% alcohol in water as the most effective range against bacteria and says the effect drops sharply below 50%, so check the label. It also notes alcohol evaporates quickly and can't penetrate protein-rich material, which is why you wash first and then let the posts stay wet with alcohol for a moment.
  • Tarnish is a chemical layer, not dirt. The Sheffield Assay Office explains that silver, and the copper alloyed with it in sterling, react with sulfur-containing gases in the air to form dark sulfides. Soap, alcohol and peroxide don't remove it; a polishing cloth or silver polish does.

So the order is clean, then disinfect, then polish if the silver is dark.

Removing tarnish, gentlest first

The general method for sterling is in how to clean tarnished sterling silver jewelry; earrings add tiny parts that trap whatever you use.

  • Polishing cloth. The Canadian Conservation Institute (CCI) calls polishing cloths most useful for buffing lightly tarnished silver. Pinch a stud in a fold of the cloth; draw a hoop through it in one direction.
  • Silver polish. For dark tarnish on plain sterling. Work a little on a soft cloth, then wash the earring again: CCI notes that polishes usually contain ammonia, which dissolves copper, and residue left in crevices can turn green.
  • Silver dip. Fast but harsh. CCI advises applying a dip locally with a cotton swab rather than immersing, rinsing with distilled water, and keeping exposure to a minimum to avoid pitting the metal. Jewelers Mutual warns that commercial silver cleaners may damage gemstones, so dips are for plain silver only.
  • Foil and baking soda. Jewelers Mutual describes lining a pan with foil, covering the earrings with baking soda and pouring boiling water over them. It works on a plain stud, but butterfly backs and hinged hoops trap the paste, and CCI notes silver cleaned with aluminum this way may tarnish more quickly than polished silver, and the Sheffield Assay Office lists foil, baking soda, toothpaste and vinegar among remedies that can cause long-term damage to silver and gemstones if used often. Keep it for an occasional rescue of plain, solid sterling, never for anything glued, plated, pearl-set or deliberately blackened. The home remedies are compared in cleaning jewelry with vinegar, baking soda or peroxide.
  • Toothpaste. Skip it. It's gritty, and on earrings it ends up wedged in the coil of a butterfly back or under a stud's setting, where a rinse won't reach.

Earrings that need a different approach

  • Silver-plated. CCI warns that any method of tarnish removal can be very damaging to silver plate, and Jewelers Mutual notes plated silver scratches and tarnishes easily. Soap and water and a light touch with a cloth, nothing stronger; more in how to clean silver-plated jewelry. Sterling is usually stamped 925 on the post or back (see what 925 and other stamps mean); if there's no mark, Metal Testing & Verification is $15 per item.
  • Oxidized or blackened designs. On blackened hoops and drops the dark lines are part of the design, so rub a cloth only over the high points and keep the earring out of any dip, which lifts the black along with the tarnish. If the dark finish has already worn away, ask for a free quote through the on-site chat or the contact page, or book the Mail-In Evaluation ($19, credited in full), before ordering anything. See cleaning oxidized silver.
  • Pearls. GIA says pearls should never go in an ultrasonic or steam cleaner and can be damaged by many chemicals, hair spray, perfume and cosmetics among them, and Jewelers Mutual says not to submerge them. Wipe the pearl with a soft cloth, clean only the silver around it, and keep alcohol and peroxide off the pearl.
  • Stones. GIA says diamonds clean safely with household detergents, and cubic zirconia takes the same soap-and-brush treatment. Jewelers Mutual groups opal and jade with pearls as stones needing extra care and no scrubbing, and anything glued shouldn't soak. More in cleaning silver jewelry with stones.
  • Rhodium-plated sterling. Many silver studs carry a thin rhodium plating that keeps tarnish off until it wears through. Use soap and water, not polish, which wears a thin plating away faster. When the silver starts to show and darken, Rhodium Plating is $89 a pair ($69 + $20).

While they're clean, check the hardware

A clean earring is the easiest time to spot the faults that lose earrings:

  • Posts that are bent, thinned near the tip or loose where they meet the earring. A wobbling post eventually snaps. Earring Post Repair replaces it by soldering or laser welding, never glue: from $30 a pair in silver for stick posts, $20 for a single earring.
  • Backs that slide on with no resistance no longer grip. See finding a replacement earring back.
  • Hinged hoops that don't click shut: Hinge Repair, from $45 for earrings.
  • A worn leverback that no longer snaps shut: Earring Post Repair with the leverback style, $60 a pair in sterling silver ($30 + $30).
  • Itchy or red earlobes. The American Academy of Dermatology names earrings and earring backs among the biggest sources of nickel exposure, says more than 18 percent of people in North America are allergic to nickel, and lists sterling silver among the metals to choose instead. If your ears still react, see rhodium plating for sensitive ears; a piercing that is red, sore or weeping is a question for a doctor.

When a professional clean is worth it, and what it costs

Jewelers Mutual recommends a professional cleaning at least once a year. Send earrings in when tarnish sits deep in filigree or around settings you can't reach, when stones stay dull after washing, or when a post, back or hinge needs work anyway. JewelryRepair.com is the mail-in service of Sky Jewelry, family jewelers on Lenox Avenue in New York, with over 50,000 repairs since 1989. For earrings:

  • Jewelry Spa: $44 for silver earrings. An ultrasonic bath loosens what's packed around posts and settings, steam blasts it out, and a hand polish and written inspection report follow. 14K yellow gold earrings are $59 ($44 + $10 + $5).
  • Jewelry Polishing: $30 for silver earrings, for heavy tarnish and fine scratches.
  • Rhodium Plating: $89 for silver earrings ($69 + $20).
  • Every repair price already includes a clean and polish and the 1-year workmanship guarantee, so a post repair comes back clean too.
  • Pearl earrings need a different clean, since GIA rules out ultrasonic and steam for pearls, so ask through the contact page first.

Be realistic about small jobs: shipping is $30 round trip per order by UPS, so on a single $30 polish it doubles the cost. Mail-in makes most sense when several pieces go in one box, since shipping is the same however many are inside, or when the earrings need a repair as well. Each pair is photographed the day it arrives and again before it leaves, and a second jeweler checks every post and back.

Questions

Can I clean silver earrings with rubbing alcohol?
Yes, to disinfect them, though it won't remove tarnish. Wash off the grime first with soap and water, since the CDC notes alcohol can't penetrate protein-rich material, then wipe or dip the posts and hooks and let them air-dry. The CDC gives 60% to 90% alcohol in water as the most effective range. Keep alcohol off pearls, and polish tarnish separately with a silver cloth.
Is hydrogen peroxide safe for sterling silver earrings?
Only as a quick wipe: 3% peroxide on plain silver posts disinfects them, but don't soak sterling in it, and rinse and dry it straight away. It isn't a tarnish remover, and rubbing alcohol does the same disinfecting job. Jewelers Mutual lists either one for extra disinfection. Keep peroxide off pearls, which GIA says many chemicals can damage, and lift tarnish with a polishing cloth instead.
How do you get black tarnish off silver earrings?
Use a silver polish on a soft cloth, a small area at a time, then wash the earrings again so no polish stays in the crevices. Black means the tarnish layer is thick, so a cloth alone is slow. On plain sterling, a dip dabbed on with a cotton swab and rinsed well also works. Professionally, Jewelry Polishing for silver earrings is $30 at JewelryRepair.com.
How often should I clean my earrings?
Daily-wear earrings deserve a wash every week or two, Jewelers Mutual suggests, and pairs kept for occasions about monthly. Use each clean as a check: wiggle each post where it meets the earring, push the backs on to feel whether they still grip, and close each hinged hoop to hear it click. A post that moves or a back that slides on freely is the time to have it fixed, before the earring is lost.
Why do my silver earrings turn black so fast?
Usually humidity, skin and storage. The Sheffield Assay Office says silver tarnishes faster as humidity rises, recommends keeping it below 50%, and names perfume, hairspray, body lotion and foundation as things that make it more prone to tarnish. Rubber bands and wool contain sulfur, and wooden drawers speed tarnish too, the Assay Office adds. Put earrings in after hair and makeup, and store them dry in a tarnish-reducing pouch.
Is a jewelry cleaner or ultrasonic cleaner safe for silver earrings?
For plain, solid sterling studs and hoops, yes, if the cleaner's label says it's for silver. Stones, pearls and glue change that: Jewelers Mutual warns commercial silver cleaners may damage gemstones, GIA says ultrasonic and steam can loosen stones and should never be used on pearls, and glued parts shouldn't soak. For those pairs, soap, water and a soft brush are the safe choice. More in are ultrasonic cleaners safe for jewelry?