Jewelry repair questions · Metals, plating & finishing
Does silver-plated jewelry tarnish?
From JewelryRepair.com: over 50,000 repairs since 1989 · 4.9 from 187 Google reviews (as of )
The short version
- Yes, it tarnishes. The silver surface reacts with sulfur in the air exactly as sterling does.
- It has a second problem sterling doesn't: the silver is a thin skin over brass, copper, nickel silver or steel, and once it wears through, the base metal can darken or turn green.
- Cleaning is where plate gets lost. Abrasive polishes, pastes and frequent rubbing take the silver off with the tarnish.
- Fine-silver plate tarnishes more slowly than sterling, because the layer contains no copper, but it still tarnishes.
- Gold-, rhodium- or platinum-plated silver resists tarnish until that top layer wears through.
- Not sure which you have? A plated piece may not be stamped Sterling or Coin, and stamps can be missing or wrong, so testing settles it.
Prices
| Service | Price | What's included |
|---|---|---|
| Metal Testing & Verification | $15 | Hallmarks checked under magnification, then the metal tested and the result documented, so you know whether a piece is sterling or plated before you clean, polish or repair it. |
| Mail-In Evaluation | $19 | A jeweler examines the whole piece under magnification and sends an itemized quote with photos. Approve all, some or none; the $19 is credited in full toward approved work. |
| Rhodium Plating | from $74 plated / fashion | A non-tarnishing white layer over worn fashion jewelry, using the Gold-plated / fashion option: ring or pendant $74 ($69 + $5), earrings or bracelet $94 ($69 + $20 + $5), necklace $114 ($69 + $40 + $5). The base metal is confirmed on arrival, and you approve any change first. |
| Gold Plating | from $60 | If you'd rather switch to gold: flash plating in yellow gold for a ring or pendant is $60 over silver and $173 over brass ($60 + $113). Thicker layers and rose or white finishes add to it. |
Why plated silver tarnishes, and what's underneath
Silver plate is a thin layer of silver bonded to a cheaper metal, most often by electroplating. The silver behaves like any silver: the Canadian Conservation Institute (CCI) explains that it reacts with sulfur gases, mainly hydrogen sulfide, forming silver sulfide that looks yellow while thin and black once thick, and that humid air speeds the reaction. Copper is what makes sterling tarnish faster than pure silver, so plate made of fine silver tarnishes more slowly than a sterling chain would. It still darkens.
What really sets plate apart is the base metal, and with it how the piece ages once the silver thins:
- Brass (copper and zinc), a common base in fashion jewelry: where the plate wears through, it darkens and can leave green marks on skin.
- Copper: tarnishes dark, and its corrosion is green or blue-green. CCI notes polish residue can come away green when copper is present under the plating or in the silver alloy, so green alone doesn't prove plate.
- Nickel silver: about 60% copper, 20% nickel and 20% zinc, chosen as a plating base because its color is close to silver's. Despite the name, it contains no silver.
- Stainless steel: resists corrosion on its own, thanks to a thin chromium-rich oxide layer, so worn spots look gray rather than tarnishing or turning green.
How to tell silver plate from sterling
- Read the stamp. Under the National Stamping Act, a silver-plated article may not be stamped sterling or coin. CCI notes that EPNS marks silver electroplated onto nickel silver, and EPBM silver plated onto Britannia metal. A piece stamped 925, Sterling or Ster. on its own is being sold as solid silver.
- Read the description. The FTC's Jewelry Guides say calling a coated product silver can mislead unless it's qualified to show it's only coated, and that silver plate should cover all significant surfaces and be of reasonable durability. They set no minimum thickness for silver plate, unlike vermeil, which needs a 10K-or-better gold layer over sterling with a minimum thickness equivalent to 2.5 microns of fine gold.
- Look at the edges. Plate wears first at edges, clasps, ring undersides and other high points. A yellow, pink or brassy tone showing through means another metal underneath. Green marks alone don't settle it, since sterling contains 7.5% copper too. Sterling is silver all the way through.
- Test it. Stamps can be missing or wrong. Metal Testing & Verification is $15 per item at JewelryRepair.com: hallmarks checked, the metal tested and the result documented.
Plate by plate: which ones tarnish
- Silver-plated brass or copper: tarnishes on the surface, then darkens or goes green where the plate wears through. This combination is the one most likely to mark skin; see do brass and copper jewelry tarnish?
- Silver-plated stainless steel: the silver tarnishes, but the steel under it resists rust and corrosion, so worn spots simply look gray.
- Sterling silver plated with gold: the gold layer resists tarnish. Sold as vermeil, its gold layer must be at least 10K and equivalent to 2.5 microns of fine gold; where it wears thin, the sterling underneath can tarnish. More in does gold vermeil tarnish?
- Rhodium- or platinum-plated silver: won't tarnish while the plating is intact, because rhodium doesn't normally form an oxide and platinum doesn't tarnish. Once sterling shows through, those spots can. See does rhodium-plated jewelry tarnish?
- Silver-plated pieces with cubic zirconia: the stones don't tarnish, but the plated metal around them does, and tarnish packs in around the settings where a cloth can't reach.
- Does silver plate rust? Only if the base is iron or plain steel. Rust is iron oxide; copper and brass corrode green or brown instead, which isn't called rust.
How to clean and protect it without stripping the plate
Treat silver plate as a finish you can only remove at home, never restore. CCI describes a silver-plated copper tray that lost its silver layer to repeated cleaning with an abrasive polish, and GIA warns that abrasives can erode metal. In practice:
- Wash it in lukewarm water with a drop of mild dish soap, rinse, and pat it completely dry.
- Use a silver polishing cloth lightly, only on tarnished spots, and stop at the first hint of a yellow or pink tone.
- Skip pastes, toothpaste, baking soda and multi-purpose metal polish. Skip dips too: CCI warns that dips can over-clean and pit silver, and plate has very little silver to spare.
- Store it like sterling: dry, sealed in a small bag with an anti-tarnish strip, away from humidity. Our guide to keeping silver from tarnishing covers storage, and how to clean silver-plated jewelry covers cleaning step by step.
When the plate is worn through: what can and can't be done
Once the base metal shows, no cleaning brings the silver back; only a new layer of metal does. Here is what JewelryRepair.com, the mail-in repair service of Sky Jewelry in New York, does and doesn't offer:
- Silver re-plating isn't on the JewelryRepair.com menu.
- Rhodium plating gives worn fashion jewelry a bright white surface that doesn't tarnish. Rhodium Plating lists a Gold-plated / fashion option at +$5, so a ring or pendant is $74 ($69 + $5). Rhodium is a highly reflective silvery-white metal, so expect a slightly brighter, whiter look than silver. How well a particular base metal takes plating is confirmed when the piece arrives, and if the plan changes, you approve it first.
- Gold plating is an option if you'd like a different color: Gold Plating starts at $60 over silver and $173 over brass ($60 + $113) for flash plating on a ring or pendant.
- Solder repairs and polishing on plated pieces are priced by free quote, because heat and abrasion both affect plating.
- Not sure it's worth it? The Mail-In Evaluation is $19, credited in full toward approved work: a jeweler examines the piece under magnification and sends an itemized quote with photos. Approve all, some or none.
Before you send a plated piece, photograph the worn spots yourself so you can compare them with the arrival photos, and pack it so it can't rub against other jewelry in the box, since friction in transit wears plate too. Shipping is $30 round trip per order by UPS and covers the return even if you decline the quote. JewelryRepair.com is run by Sky Jewelry, family jewelers on Lenox Avenue who have completed over 50,000 repairs since 1989.
Questions
Does fine silver-plated jewelry tarnish?
Does silver-plated jewelry tarnish faster than sterling?
Will silver-plated jewelry turn my skin green?
Can I use a silver polishing cloth on silver-plated jewelry?
Can silver-plated jewelry be re-plated?
Is silver-plated jewelry the same as sterling silver?
Related
JewelryRepair.com · Over 50,000 repairs since 1989
More repair questions · Repair glossary · How online jewelry repair works · Full price list